FACT CHECKER:
MEDICAID REFORM IN MONTANA
What the 2019 Medicaid Reform & Integrity Act does:
The Medicaid Reform and Integrity Act (HB 658) continues Medicaid coverage to certain low-income Montanans while adding measures to increase program accountability, improve transparency, and reduce financial burden on the state’s general fund. The Act established community engagement (paid or volunteer work) requirements for participants, revised eligibility verification procedures, and imposed a new tax on hospitals to help pay for the program.
What it does NOT do:
Make any changes to covered services, including abortion services or gender reassignment surgeries.
Sources:
Montana Department of Labor Report “Montana Medicaid & Montana Employers.” January 8, 2019.
2019 Navigant Report, “Analysis of the Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Montana.”
THE CLAIM
The 2019 Montana Medicaid Reform bill increased abortion services.
THE truth
The Medicaid Reform bill (HB 658) did not change any of the healthcare services covered by Medicaid. Federal statute (law) provides for the services the state can cover under its Medicaid plan. In fact, federal law prohibits federal funds from being used for abortion services except in the limited cases of rape, incest, or if a woman suffers from a life-threatening physical injury or illness that would place the woman in danger of death unless an abortion is performed. The Montana Medicaid Reform and Integrity Act 2019 took measures to increase accountability and transparency in the administering of Medicaid expansion in Montana and cannot change federal law.
Sources:
Montana Medicaid Reform & Integrity Act 2019
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Memo to State Medicaid Administrators, www.medicaid.gov
Karen Costello
President of Holy Rosary Healthcare, Miles City
Sidney Herald
"It is regrettable, however, that some are accusing those brave lawmakers who stood with us that their support of Medicaid reform meant that taxpayer-funded abortions would occur under the legislation. This is false. As a non-profit Catholic healthcare organization and consistent with our ethical and religious directives, Holy Rosary Healthcare does not perform abortions in our facility. Indeed, we would not have supported the Medicaid reform legislation last session if it provided for taxpayer-funded abortions. Those who argue otherwise are incorrect.”
THE truth
The Medicaid reform bill (HB 658) did not change any of the healthcare services covered by Medicaid, rather it reformed the existing program to increase accountability of the services offered and participants covered. Medicaid expansion is a federally-supported program administered by the state with 90% of funding provided by the federal government. As a result, covered services are defined at the federal level. Services and procedures provided to patients must meet the criteria of medically necessary and do not include any experimental or clinically unproven procedures. Medical necessity is determined by clinical standards of care - not by lawmakers.
Medicaid pays for procedures that aren't medically necessary.
THE CLAIM
THE CLAIM
Legislators who worked to reform Medicaid should be punished.
THE truth
A vote to reform the system was a vote to make Medicaid more transparent, accountable and effective. Like any piece of legislation, all Montanans expect their elected officials to work to represent them and make sure the law works in our unique state with our unique circumstances. Regrettably, most of the attacks on the legislators who rolled up their sleeves to reform the legislation are coming from individuals who are more interested in scoring political points and taking away healthcare coverage from working Montanans.
After Medicaid expansion was enacted in 2015, more than 90,000 Montanans had access to healthcare which provided an enormous benefit to Montana businesses – in fact, almost 60% of Montana businesses benefitted by having employees covered by the new Medicaid expansion.
80 percent of Medicaid beneficiaries are in working families. Among those not working, over 1 in 3 are ill or disabled. Medicaid expansion has drastically reduced the need for charity care, which helps keep our hospitals financially viable.
Those who aim to roll back Medicaid don’t seem to understand that it has created or supported 9,700 Montana jobs, $793 million in new and sustained wages and created $2 billion in new economic activity since its passage. At a time when our nation is reeling from the economic and health ripple effects of COVID-19, access to healthcare and the viability of our healthcare providers are more critical than ever.
As Montana healthcare providers on the front line face the unprecedented strain of the COVID-19 pandemic, it’s important for Montanans to understand that the 2019 Medicaid Reform and Integrity Act (HB 658) was an essential piece of legislation in helping fortify our healthcare infrastructure.
Sources:
Montana Department of Labor Report “Montana Medicaid & Montana Employers.” January 8, 2019.
2019 Navigant Report, “Analysis of the Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Montana.”
THE truth
The I-185 citizens’ initiative was two-fold: it attempted to increase tobacco taxes in order to finance Medicaid expansion.
Big Tobacco dumped unprecedented money into Montana in order to stop the tax increase and protect its bottom line. And it worked. However, the truth is: expanding healthcare isn’t a red or a blue issue: it’s a Montana value.
THE CLAIM
Montanans voted down I-185 because they don't support Medicaid.
THE CLAIM
Medicaid is bad for Montana.
THE truth
The economic benefits of Medicaid expansion have far and away exceeded costs. Medicaid expansion has added $600 million in economic output to Montana’s economy each year. It has fueled 9,715 jobs, $793 million in associated wages and $30.5 million in new state tax revenue.
3 in 5 Montana employers have workers enrolled in Medicaid. Medicaid expansion has allowed tens of thousands of working Montanans to address pent-up healthcare needs. Access to healthcare services promotes a healthier workforce and strengthens the earning potential for individuals and families.
Sources:
Montana Department of Labor Report “Montana Medicaid & Montana Employers.” January 8, 2019.
2019 Navigant Report, “Analysis of the Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Montana.”
THE CLAIM
We need leaders in the Montana legislature who will work toward commonsense solutions to our state's healthcare needs.
